September 9, 2007
Reasons for Initiating a project
We in the industry all know, there is a plethora of reasons for initiating a project. Before we had a structured request method for project at one place, several ITers never lunched in he cafeteria because it just created a long streaming request pool of which was unprioritized. So let's discuss structured decision criteria aligned with strategic directives. According to PMI, organizations typically have 6 prime reasons for initiating a project:
- Market Demand
- Business Need
- Customer Request
- Technological Advance
- Legal Requirement
- Social Need
I think it would be an interesting exercise to relate these needs to the five pillars of healthcare: Services, People, Financial, Growth, and Quality. As sometimes technology is necessary to be in existence, I'd like to suggest agreeming upon an infrastructure category. For example, having smart infusion pumps require an 802.11 wireless network, but not an RFID functionality (if the tracking is being offered via 802.11, sometimes the RFID component of this just doesn’t pay for itself) So a wireless network is a required technology building block for a smart infusion pumps deployment.
An example of decision criteria with semi-fictious descriptions and examples.
Decision Criteria |
Descriptions and Examples |
|---|---|
Services |
|
Improve Patient Satisfaction |
~ Improves Responsiveness to Patient’s Needs ~ Improves Convenience for Appointments and Procedures |
Improve Clinical Outcomes |
~ Improve Quality of Care and Patient Safety (Reduce Medical Error Rates
|
Improves Community Relations and Outreach |
~ Improves referrals from community physicians. |
People |
|
Physician Relations & Satisfaction |
~ Improves access to online information at the point of care |
Employee Satisfaction |
~ Attract, recruit & retain high-performing workforce ~ Improve management controls of overtime and shift placement |
Financial |
|
Enhances Operational Efficiency |
~ Turn around Times are reduced. ~ Patient Flow is Optimized. ~ Standardize Hospital Information System to reduce costs |
Strong Return on Investment |
~ Payback Period within five years ~ Internal Rate of Return at 12%. |
Growth |
|
Improves Market Share |
~ Support new/enhanced clinical strategies (Cardiology, Stroke Center, Orthopedics)
|
Improves Competitive Advantage |
~ Assures Inpatient, Outpatient, Rehab, and Long Term Care Growth |
Quality and Patient Safety |
|
Align with Regulatory Requirements |
~ Project directly supports regulatory compliance, e.g. JACHO, HIPAA, OIG Guidelines, CMS guidelines, HEDIS guidelines, UNOS Reporting. |
Process Improvement |
~ Six Sigma Process Improvement Projects |
Addresses Significant Deficiencies |
~ Adverse Events are proactively detected and averted in a timely manner. |
Infrastructure |
|
Technology Building Block |
~ Supports enhancing the exchange of information ~ Supports future technology additions. |
Required Application Maintenance |
~ Application has been retired. |
Provides Essential Infrastructure |
~ Moves from Microsoft and Novell to Linux |
Aligning this with PMI standards would be as follows:
Decision Criteria |
Descriptions and Examples |
|---|---|
Market Need |
|
Improves Market Share |
~ Support new/enhanced clinical strategies (Cardiology, Stroke Center, Orthopedics)
|
Improves Competitive Advantage |
~ Assures Inpatient, Outpatient, Rehab, and Long Term Care Growth |
Business Need |
|
Physician Relations & Satisfaction |
~ Improves access to online information at the point of care |
Improve Patient Satisfaction |
~ Improves Responsiveness to Patient’s Needs ~ Improves Convenience for Appointments and Procedures |
Improve Clinical Outcomes |
~ Improve Quality of Care and Patient Safety (Reduce Medical Error Rates
|
Strong Return on Investment |
~ Payback Period within five years ~ Internal Rate of Return at 12%. |
Customer Request |
|
Process Improvement |
~ Six Sigma Process Improvement Projects |
Addresses Significant Deficiencies |
~ Adverse Events are proactively detected and averted in a timely manner. |
Enhances Operational Efficiency |
~ Turn around Times are reduced. ~ Patient Flow is Optimized. ~ Standardize Hospital Information System to reduce costs |
Employee Satisfaction |
~ Attract, recruit & retain high-performing workforce ~ Improve management controls of overtime and shift placement |
Technology Advancement |
|
Technology Building Block |
~ Supports enhancing the exchange of information ~ Supports future technology additions. |
Required Application Maintenance |
~ Application has been retired. |
Provides Essential Infrastructure |
~ Moves from Microsoft and Novell to Linux |
Legal Requirement |
|
Align with Regulatory Requirements |
~ Project directly supports regulatory compliance, e.g. JACHO, HIPAA, OIG Guidelines, CMS guidelines, HEDIS guidelines, UNOS reporting |
Social Need |
|
Improves Community Relations and Outreach |
~ Improves referrals from community physicians. |
So what was the purpose of this exercise? The 6 prime reasons for initiating a project can be used as a part of project selection criteria, and again aligned with the strategic relevance. Although I strongly recommend having the discussion of strategic goals and cascading those throughout the decision criteria. The important point is that the decision criteria must be applicable across the project request pool and without exception before project selection. This standardizes the process and implements a best practice.
Finally passed the test
Managing in light of McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
CMMI
Kicking HIT Leadership Up a Notch
That's just some mumbo jumbo project management BS
Outcomes - The tactic to get to the strategy
Nurse Call, VOIP, and Wi-Fi: Its just cool when things come together!
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
August 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
Joel on Software
David Ross
Edward Prevost
Martin Fowler
The Health Care Blog
The Tales of Hoffman
The Business Word
Medical Rants
Christina's Considerations
Paul Levy
HIS Talk
Appropriate IT
Candid CIO
RSS feed




